Whether Instacart is worth it depends on how often you order, how large your orders are, and which fees apply. Based on reported prices, Instacart+ may pay off only for frequent orders. One secondary source suggests about two or more orders a month as a rough rule, which is not exact. This article covers the customer side only, not working as an Instacart shopper.
Every source below is a secondary site, and none is dated. Instacart's own pages were not available for this article, so check current prices there before deciding. The FTC's own notice was also not available, so the settlement details below are unverified.
What does Instacart cost, and which fees add up?
Four costs can apply to an order:
- Delivery fee. One source reports $5.99 on orders of $35 or more for non-members.
- Service fee. The same source reports about 5%, capped at $20. Another source says there is no single percentage for all orders, so treat this as an example, not a rule.
- Tip. A suggested tip of about 10% is reported. A tip goes to the person who shops and delivers, and the amount is your choice.
- Item prices. Retailers set them, and they can be higher than in store (Plottdata says "sometimes"). Markup estimates of 10-20% and 15-30% circulate, but neither is sourced, so the size is unconfirmed.
Pickup orders reportedly carry no service fee, though some retailers charge a pickup fee.
A rough example, with caveats
Take the reported figures as an illustration only. On a qualifying order, a non-member could face a $5.99 delivery fee, a service fee that varies by order, and a tip of about 10%. Item prices could add more if the retailer's online prices are higher than shelf prices. These numbers come from a single secondary source and may be out of date. Your checkout screen shows the actual total, so compare it with the shelf prices for the same items before you commit.
Is Instacart+ worth it? A break-even illustration
Instacart+ is reported at $99 per year or $9.99 per month. Members get $0 delivery on qualifying orders. Sources disagree on the minimum: one says $35, another says $10, citing the current benefits page. Check the figure on Instacart's site.
Here is the arithmetic. If a membership replaces a $5.99 delivery fee, $99 is recovered after about 16.5 deliveries, so 17 orders (The Pricer). That is an illustration, not a measured result. MoneyLion puts the figure nearer 25 orders, because its assumptions differ.
The two figures differ because each source assumes different savings per order. If your orders carry smaller savings, it takes longer to break even. If the minimum order size is not met, the membership saves nothing on that order.
Membership does not remove every charge. Service fees and item price differences can remain. If you order a few times a year, paying per order is likely cheaper. If you order weekly, the math looks better, but only if your fees match these examples.
Questions to ask before joining
- How many orders did you place in the past year, and how many met the minimum?
- What delivery fees did you actually pay on those orders?
- Would pickup or an in-store trip have done the same job?
- Is the monthly plan, which you can stop, a better test than paying for a year up front?
These are general prompts, not personal financial advice.
What did the FTC settlement allege, and what does Instacart say?
Secondary sources report a $60 million settlement with the Federal Trade Commission, with a stipulated order entered January 13, 2026, in the Northern District of California. A stipulated order is one both sides agree to. According to one source, the complaint alleged that service fees in challenged promotions added up to 15%, and that a satisfaction guarantee was hard to redeem. Those are allegations. Instacart says it "flatly" denies wrongdoing (Lawcompensate).
Refund details, such as who qualifies, amounts and the administrator, were not announced in the sources. Some sites cite "up to $50", which is unconfirmed. Look for the FTC's own notice before acting on any claim form. Be careful with sites that ask for payment or sensitive details to "claim" a refund.
What are the cheaper alternatives to Instacart?
- Pay per order. Skip the membership if you order rarely.
- Pickup. It reportedly avoids the service fee, though some retailers charge a pickup fee.
- Shop in store. No delivery fees, and no markup beyond shelf price. You pay with your own time and travel.
- Other delivery services. MoneyLion mentions Amazon and Whole Foods delivery. Its terms were not verified here.
To compare any paid program on the same terms, see how to evaluate an online program.
What is the bottom line?
For occasional orders, paying per order or choosing pickup is likely the cheaper route, based on the reported fees. For weekly orders, Instacart+ may pay off, but only if the delivery minimum, your order sizes and your fees line up. The evidence here is thin: every source is secondary and undated, and the figures conflict in places. Confirm current prices and terms on Instacart's own pages, and use the FTC's site for anything about the settlement.
FAQ
Does Instacart+ remove all fees?
No. It is reported to remove delivery fees on qualifying orders, but service fees and item price differences can remain. Check the benefits page for current terms.
Are Instacart prices higher than in the store?
Sometimes. Retailers set item prices, and they can be higher than shelf prices. Estimates of the markup conflict and are unsourced, so compare a few items yourself.
How many orders does it take for Instacart+ to pay off?
One source calculates about 17 orders a year at $5.99 per delivery. Another says about 25. Your own fees decide the answer.
Is Instacart a scam?
No regulator or court has called it one in the sources reviewed. The FTC matter ended in a settlement, and Instacart denies wrongdoing.